Please see my Video talks live on You Tube!Share and Subscribe!Circulate please!
Here you are!
- Palash Biswas uploaded, posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 1 day ago
PPP model of honesty which is striped NAKED!Pl see:Samvidhaan - Episode 1/10
See What RSS Planning in India... Weapons, Hate, and Destroy..लीजिये,तैयार है आपको जिबह करने के लिए हिंदुस्तानी गिलोटिन!
- Palash Biswas uploaded, posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 6 days ago
मां काली को दंगाई बना दिया बंगाल में तो बंट गया भारत!
उसी दंगा फसाद से बनायेंगे हिंदू राष्ट्र? आज के प्रवचन का मकसद है,अखंड और विभाजित भारत की लोक जमीन पर खड़े होकर देहात भारतकी धड़कनों को सुनना।
बंगाल में एक कवि हुआ करते थे,जसीमुद्दीन।पल्ली कवि जसीमुद्दीन।
- Palash Biswas uploaded, posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 1 week ago
শ্মশান কালী,ভদ্রকালী,রক্ষা কালী,কালিঘাটে কালি আবার দক্ষিণেশ্বরে কালী!
বলির পাঁঠা পাঁঠি বুঝিবে না মুদিখানা রম রম কালীর বর
সেই বর,ভূতের রাজা দিল বর,তিন বর জব্বর
গুন্ডামি যত রকম,মাফিয়া রাষ্ট্র,সন্ত্রাস
প্রভূ কহিলেন হাঁকি,ভূত প্রেত এব করিব ধ্বংস
দাঁত কেলাইয়া ভাবতাছি,বহুতে মজা,কেযা বাত!
বলির পাঁঠা পাঁঠি বুঝিবে না মুদিখানা রম রম কালীর বর
সেই বর,ভূতের রাজা দিল বর,তিন বর জব্বর
গুন্ডামি যত রকম,মাফিয়া রাষ্ট্র,সন্ত্রাস!
প্রভূ কহিলেন হাঁকি,ভূত প্রেত এব করিব ধ্বংস
দাঁত কেলাইয়া ভাবতাছি,বহুতে মজা,কেয়...
- Palash Biswas posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 1 week ago
What I have been saying!'Everything the West has done was to create ISIS' – John Pilger
- Palash Biswas uploaded, posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 1 week ago
यह ड्रामा प्रेम का रसायनशास्त्र जितना है उससे कहीं ज्यादा सियासती मजहब और मजहबी सियासत का किस्सा है तो उसका भौतिकी शास्त्र भी है।
माफिया,दहशतगर्द, गुंडे हुकूमत पैदा करती है। पालती, मारती भी वह ही है।
- Palash Biswas uploaded and posted 2 weeks ago
Save the Ganges!
Save the Himalayas!
Save ourselves,us,the Indians and the Indian Nation!
Ganges flows from the Mansarovar,most recent studies confirm and Uma Bharati acknowledged!
Welcome!Mark Zuckerberg Vows to Donate 99% of His Facebook Shares for Charity!Welcome!Mark Zuckerberg!
- Palash Biswas uploaded, posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 2 weeks ago
वेदमंत्र में हर मुश्किल आसान,हिंदुत्व एजंडा फिर क्यों मुक्त बाजार और सुधार पर खामोशी क्यों समता और समामाजिक न्याय और हमारे नुमाइंदे क्यों खामोश?
बंगाल में 35 साल के राजकाज गवाँने के बाद कामरेडों को यद आया कि रिजर्वेशन कोटा लागू नहीं और धर्मोन्मादी ध्रूवीकरण के मुकाबला फिर बहुजन समाज की याद बंगाल में भी मंडल बनाम कमंडल?
- Palash Biswas uploaded, posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 2 weeks ago
सच कहा है अरुंधति ने, जाति व्यवस्था को बनाये रखना ही ब्राह्मणवाद है
यह #दंगा फसाद और ग्लोबल आर्डर पर कब्जे का #धर्मोन्मादी #मुक्तबाजारी एजेंडा दरअसल हमारा ही खून बहाने का जुध महाजुध है
- Palash Biswas uploaded, posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 2 weeks ago
दीवारें जो गिरायें,वो उल्लू दा पट्ठा!
इसीलिए इतिहास लहूलुहान,पन्ना दर पन्ना खून का सैलाब!
लहुलुहान फिजां है
लहुलुहान स्वतंत्रता
लहुलुहान संप्रभुता
लहूलुहान इनडिविजुअल
लहुलूहान ट्राडिशन
लहूलुहान यह कायनात
और यह कयामत का मंजर
- Palash Biswas uploaded, posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 2 weeks ago
Shekespeare and Comedy discussed in modern Times!
- Palash Biswas uploaded and posted 3 weeks ago
यावज्जीवेत्सुखं जीवेत् ऋणं कृत्वा घृतं पिबेत् ।
भस्मीभूतस्य देहस्य पुनरागमनं कुतः ।।
त्रयोवेदस्य कर्तारौ भण्डधूर्तनिशाचराः ।
Rushdie and Taslima do not belong to the most reputed school of Atheism but they provoke Islamophobia as the governance of Fascism is banking on this bleeding ATM.They do not stand with Charvak,Shelly or Bhagat Singh.
- Palash Biswas uploaded, posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 3 weeks ago
Swaraj:Rapidly growing Ayurvedic and Herbal Pie with religious Flavour!
फिल्म हैदर के जरिये हमने कश्मीर को देखा है।
पंजाब पर फिल्म देखने की जरुरत नहीं है।
अस्सी का दशक है,जहां फिर हम लौट रहे हैं।
सवाल यह है कि क्या हम फिर आपरेशन ब्लू स्टार का विकल्प चुनने की राह पर है?
सवाल यह भी है कि क्या यह हिंदू राष्ट्र फिर सिखों का नरसंहार दोहराने पर आमादा है?
- Palash Biswas uploaded, posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 3 weeks ago
#Julius Caesar#Brutas# Greek tagedy # RSS #Shakespeare#Bajrangi Brigade# #Sovereignty#Democracy#Integrity#Unity#Indira Gandhi#1984#Plight of the Sikhs#Rajiv Gandhi #Srilanka #Mujib #Benzir#Sadat#Lincoln#Kennedy#Hinduta#Durga#Toharaia#Mahanta#Sadhwi #Babri Mosque# Advani# Rama #Riots #Godhra#Bhopal#Guajarat#Assam
- Palash Biswas uploaded, posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 4 weeks ago
Thanks to You Tube,I have including news clips all about Seventh Pay commission and the impact, Disinvestment drive and the reform policy,explained it with the Negroid Caliban Speech in The Tempest and the film Avtar,explained the phenomenon of retrenchment, intolerance and partition focusing on Manto,the Pakistani Film,an interviw with director Sharmad by Manto`s niece, a short film Shalwar and finally,Toba Tek Singh,the DD film which involved Rahi Masoom Raza and Kaifi Azmi with all about u...
- Palash Biswas uploaded, posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 4 weeks ago
हाथ कंगन को आरसी क्या ?
पढ़ लें समकाीन तीसरी दुनिया का सितंबर अंक और इजराइली अमेरिकी कनेक्शन के वीडियो सबूत पेश करने के बाद बाकी सबूत भी हम लाइव शेयर कर रहे हैं जो हैंगआउट पर लाइव स्ट्रीम भी है।
आज प्रवचन दोपहर बाद ही शुरु कर पा रहा हूं क्योंकि आज हफ्तेभर बाद सब्जियां लाने सोदपुर हाट गया तो तमाम कारोबारियों,सब्जीवालं,मिठाईवालों,किरानेवालों के सात गपशप और उनके सवालों के जवाब में वहीं प्रवचन हो गया।चाय भी उनके साथ पी।यह सरासर गलत है कि आम जनता कुछ नहीं समझती। मैं हूबहू यही बातें जब सार्वजिनक स...
- Palash Biswas uploaded, posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 1 month ago
Thanks You Tube!Sharing evidences how Israel created ISIS with US help to destroy Islam!Tracked Indian leaders and shared the ISIS threat video with and shared also the videos of the LIVE War afresh in the middle east with a Red Alarm that India becomes the WAR Zone.Dare not scream for your soul and conscience but face the Truth!
- Palash Biswas uploaded, posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 1 month ago
Thanks You Tube.I have included the clippings from the biopic on Voltaire to understand Paris,France and the history of Europe and Les Miserables.Included the official trailer of the film,Bermuda Triangle, a documentary on Bermuda Triangle.Bhojpuri Songs on Chhath Puja included and also had the clippings of Paris in mourning with G 20 summit and analysed the phenomenon of humanity,freedom and universal brotherhood endangered.Cry Humanity! Cry!
- Palash Biswas uploaded and posted 1 month ago
হে মোর চিত্ত,পূণ্য তীর্থে জাগো রে ধীরে-- এই ভারতের মহামানবের সাগরতীরে। হেথায় দাঁড়ায়ে দু-বাহু বাড়ায়ে নমি নর-দেবতারে, উদার ছন্দে পরমানন্দে বন্দন করি তাঁরে। ধ্যান-গম্ভীর এই যে ভূধর, নদীজপমালাধৃত প্রান্তর, হেথায় নিত্য হেরো পবিত্র ধরিত্রীরে এই ভারতের মহামানবের সাগরতীরে। কেহ নাহি জানে কার আহ্বানে কত মানুষের ধারা দুর্বার স্রোতে এল কোথা হতে সমুদ্রে হল হারা। হেথায় আর্য, হেথা অনার্য হেথায় দ্রাবিড়, চীন-- শক-হুন-দল প...
- Palash Biswas uploaded, posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 1 month ago
#ModiInUK: ब्रिटिश मीडिया ने कहा- भारत में है हिंदू तालिबान का राज
- Palash Biswas uploaded, posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 1 month ago
सिंहद्वार पर दस्तक भारी,जाग सकै तो जाग म्हारा देश!
1 Here's a knocking indeed! If a man were
2 porter of Hell Gate, he should have old turning the
3 key. (Knock.) Knock, knock, knock! Who's there,
4 i' the name of Beelzebub? Here's a farmer, that hang'd
5 himself on th' expectation of plenty. Come in time!
6 Have napkins enow about you; here you'll sweat for't.
7 (Knock.) Knock, knock! Who's there, in the other
8 devil's name? Faith, here's an equivocator...
- Palash Biswas uploaded, posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 1 month ago
We have to discus Ritwik and Subarnarekha just because,we may not celebrate just because Religious Polarization and caste equations launched afresh by institutional fascism lost the elections in Bihar and the dominant caste alliance of OBC brotherhood won resultant in so many beefs on Ginnie Bir Rinchi Baba`s Titanic Menu.We not celebrate the GOHAARA Mandate,the lost Arab Spring all on the name of Save Cow.Biharies seem not that BURBAK neither those who voted against fascism could be deporte...
- Palash Biswas uploaded, posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 1 month ago
To be, or not to be: that is the question:
Whether 'tis nobler in the mind to suffer
The slings and arrows of outrageous fortune,
Or to take arms against a sea of troubles,
And by opposing end them? To die: to sleep;
No more; and by a sleep to say we end
The heart-ache and the thousand natural shocks
That flesh is heir to, 'tis a consummation
Devoutly to be wish'd. To die, to sleep;
To sleep: perchance to dream: ay, there's the rub;
For in that sleep of death what dreams may come
When we have...
- Palash Biswas uploaded, posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 1 month ago
We,the Indian people have to chose religious partition or caste war.It is civil war yet again!It is inhuman!Come Sunday,RSS lost or won,it would not change the scenario of intolerance,unprecedented violence,Quamati MANJAR,psyche of insecurity,the continuous holocaust unless we succeed to unite India and humanity to sustain peace, pluralism, intolerance and the Nature intact,the civilization, progress,secularism!It is all about Garm Hawa!
- Palash Biswas uploaded, posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 1 month ago
Here you are! It is Dilwale Dulhania Le Jayenge yet again.We should remember the first film by SRK Bajigar in which he played a negative anti hero type role and launched his evergreen career in Indian Cinema and look he rules as Badshah of Hindustani DILODIMAG!SRK played the Anti Hero Roles in Darr as well as in Anjaam!Let us salute his courage!
- Palash Biswas uploaded, posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 1 month ago
I wanted to include some clippings right from the holocaust,partition of India and no video available on nandigramunited,my blog could be opened due to technical error.I could not afford the clippings from the Great Dictator lest it might invite copyright infringement.Please interact in this debate mandatory.
- Palash Biswas uploaded, posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 1 month ago
I am grateful to You Tube for the clippings!I am grateful to Ei Samay for Kumar Sahani interviewed which opened the opportunity for me to discuss the Partition of India,transfer of population and its impact.I extended the frame of the Webcam and the frame.It is an experiment. If you endorse it,I may present other stories of partition!
- Palash Biswas uploaded, posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 1 month ago
Indira Gandhi "I will serve my country till my last"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=56_rFuGh8aQ
Excuse me! Government of Fascism lost the MANDATE!
- Palash Biswas uploaded, posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 1 month ago
मेरी समझ में नहीं आ रहा है कि होक कलरव का आखिर क्या मतलब है अगर वह इस दुस्समय में खामोश है?
मेरी समझ में नहीं आता कि वाममोर्चे के खिलाफ परिवर्तन के आवाहन का आखिर क्या मतलब है?
क्यो मतलब है नंदीग्राम नरसंहार के विरोध का जबकि हरिपुरा में परमाणु संयंत्र लगाने का बंगाल में अब कोई विरोध नहीं है और जनवरी ,1779 में हुए मरिचझांपी नरसंहार के खिलाप पिछले 36 सालों में कोई आवाज बुलंद हुई नहीं है?
- Palash Biswas uploaded, posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 1 month ago
Our children would unite us,I hope red blue merger sooner or later as the students seem to be united in their fight for right to education,right to higher studies and right to research by the marketing agents of Knowledge economy.I have discussed economy,production system,religion and the aesthetics of creative activism and social realism,social networking and alternative media.Pl circulate.share.
- Palash Biswas uploaded, posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 1 month ago
केसरिया सत्ता अब छात्रों को भी नहीं बख्शेगी!
आग बोने वाले को अंगार की फ़सल मिलेगी!रोजगार नहीं है,शिक्षा स्मृतिबद्ध,अब शोध का मौका नहीं देगी,यूजूसी छात्र वृत्ति बंद,अब आरक्षण को लेकर लड़ना बंद भी करो!
- Palash Biswas uploaded and posted 1 month ago
Please download each video that I share subjected to unknown problems.Better to see it offline.Please share it as much as possible.I have discussed social realism in reference to Balzac, Mozart, Bach, Shakespeare, Sophocles,Kalidasa,Tagore and Indian Bhakti movement!
It was recorded on last 25th Oct but I could not upload because of unexpected technical unwanted error.Thanks You Tube to fix it.
You have to see the video if interested.
- Palash Biswas uploaded, posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 1 month ago
इस फासिज्म के मुकाबले इंसानियत के भूगोल में गौतम बुद्ध के पंचशील के पुनरुत्थानकी जरुरत है।हमीं लाल हैं।हमीं फिर नील हैं।बाकी हिंदुत्व का महागठबंधन का फासिज्म है।अगर हम प्रभुवर्ग के गुलाम वफादार कुत्ते नहीं हैं तो अब भौंकने की बारी है।कयामत का मंजर बदलने की बारी है।कायनात की रहमतें बरकतें नियामतें बहाल करने का वक्त है।
- Palash Biswas uploaded, posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 1 month ago
নীলকন্ঠ পাখির খোঁজ নেই,তবু বিসর্জন!সুন্দরবনের সধবা বিধবা মেয়েদের প্রতি মুহুর্তে চলছে বিসর্জন নীলকন্ঠ পাখিদের ছাড়া!সেই সুন্দরবনকে ধ্বংস করে আমরা গড়ছি সভ্যতার উপনিবেশ!এই শাব হিউম্যান পৃথীবীতে গেদখল হারিয়ে যাওয়া মানুষদের কোনো ছিকানা নেই!ঝড় চলছে,ভুমিক্মপ হচ্ছে,সুনামী অব্যাহত!আমারা খবর রাখিনা!আত্মঘাতী বাঙালিধ ধ্বংস করছে সেই সুন্দরবন,সেই মহাঅরণ্য,যে জলপ্রলয় থেকে রক্ষা করছে আমাদের হাজারো বছর ধরে!
মনুষত্য ও সভ্যতার জন্য এই ধ্ংস লীলা বন্ধ হোক!
- Palash Biswas uploaded, posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 1 month ago
কোথায় সেই ভারততীর্থ রবি ঠাকুরের?ধর্মোন্মাদী রাষ্ট্র ও সময়ে মহিষাসুরমর্দিনী দশ প্রহরণ ধারিণী দুর্গে বধিছে অসুর!নীল কন্ঠ পাখী থাক না থাক,বিসর্জনের ডাক ঢাকের বোল,বোধন.দেবী দর্শন,প্যান্ডেল,থিম ঝাঁপিয়ে সেই স্বেচ্ছা মৃত্যু,আত্মধ্বংস,অমোঘ বিসর্জন।কালরাত্রির শেষ নেই।দুর্যোগের শষ নেই।
- Palash Biswas uploaded and posted 1 month ago
हमें जनजागरण का इंतजार है।चूंकि जनादेश हिटलर को भी मिला था और कोई जनादेश अंतिम निर्णायक नहीं होता।मनुष्यता हर हाल में जीतती है और फासिज्म हर हाल में हारता है।भारत में भी हारने लगा है फासिज्म क्योंकि मनुष्यता की रीढ़ सीधी है फिर।
- Palash Biswas uploaded, posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 1 month ago
Kejri is an elected chief minister of an Indian State having landslide Mandate.
If the PM is empowered with the Mandate and Free to use his power,Why a CM is denied to execute the Mandate he got?Why the State and the people of Delhi should be deprived of full power and autonomy,the Constitution provides?
- Palash Biswas uploaded, posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 2 months ago
Sabita Babu speaks from the Heart of the India,where Dilon kaa Bantwara naa huaa hai naa Hoga.Please share as much as you can to save India!The Real India,the greatest pilgrimage of humanity merging so many streams of humanity!
- Palash Biswas uploaded, posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 2 months ago
It is a novel dealing social realism.I have read the most part of it and if I get your response I would read the rest yet another day!
- Palash Biswas uploaded, posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 2 months ago
It is an eye witness account of Meerut Riots in eighties where I had been working as a professional journalist during 1984 to 1990.
- Palash Biswas uploaded, posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 2 months ago
It is an eye witness account of Meerut Riots in eighties where I had been working as a professional journalist during 1984 to 1990
- Palash Biswas uploaded, posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 2 months ago
Hence,every woman in either part of Bengal sings rabindra sangeet.If pakistani women learn this music of love,our relations would be better.I hope! Sabita sang for me all the way.
- Palash Biswas uploaded, posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 2 months ago
कृपया हस्तक्षेप की मदद करें जनपक्षधर विमर्श और जनसुनवाई जारी रखने के लिए। हस्तक्षेप का अलैक्सा पर अंतर्राष्ट्रीय रैंकिंग 1,09,573 और भारत में 11,280 है।
- Palash Biswas uploaded, posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 2 months ago
Creativity is all about the acts activated to sustain humanity and nature.Reactionaries have taken over the world and Bengal remains the colony!
- Palash Biswas uploaded, posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 2 months ago
কলবার্গি থেকে ইকলাখঃ ডানপন্থী চোখরাঙানির বিরুদ্ধে সোচ্চার কাশ্মীর থেকে কন্যাকুমারী!
অসহিষ্্নুতার শেষ চাইছে দেশ,বাংলা নিরুত্তাপ!
- Palash Biswas uploaded, posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 2 months ago
सियासत,मजहब और हुकूमत अब दहशतगर्दी है।कोई देश बचा नहीं है सुरक्षित।महाबलि अमेरिका,रूस और चीन भी सुरक्षित नहीं है।दुनिया आग के हवाले है।प्रकृति जल रही है और जल रही है मनुष्यता का वद हो रहा है।
- Palash Biswas uploaded, posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 2 months ago
Please address the basic challenges faced by the Nation,the Nature and the Humanity!
- Palash Biswas uploaded, posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 2 months ago
Why should we allow Beef Ban to become the focus skipping the economic,social and political issues,burning issues which must be addressed immediately?
- Palash Biswas uploaded, posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 2 months ago
I want to sustain humanity and Nature! I want an interactive society full of love,equality and justice!
- Palash Biswas uploaded, posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 2 months ago
बाबासाहेब ईश्वर नहीं थे।उन्हें कृपया ईश्वर न बनाइये।सच का सामना कीजिये।
- Palash Biswas uploaded and posted 2 months ago
Please declassify the classified,topmost secret documents of cabinet proposals of Partition,transfer of power and transfer of population!
- Palash Biswas uploaded, posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 2 months ago
बंद करें बेगुनाहों के कत्ल का सिलसिला,बदले में हमारी जान ले लें!
- Palash Biswas uploaded, posted and added to Hangout - Sep 27, 2012 2:16:40 PM 2 months ago
Pl watch the video and share,circulate it for debate afresh!
- Palash Biswas uploaded and posted 2 months ago
वजूद टूटता रहता है।वजूद को समेटकर फिर मोर्चे पर तनकर खड़ा हो जाना है।लड़ाई जारी है।
- Palash Biswas uploaded and posted 2 months ago
For me Bhopal Gas Tragedy is the original reform and it is being further pushed on.
Please watch the video and think the impact!
- Palash Biswas uploaded and posted 2 months ago
HUMNE HATYRO KO RAB BANA DALA!
HUMNE RAB KO HATYAR BANA DALA!
The rivers are full of blood!
The oceans are full of blood!
The Himalayas bleeding!
We have closed our eyes!
- Palash Biswas uploaded and posted 2 months ago
Situation is worsening in the Himalays.In Kashmir as well as in Nepal.Unprecedented violence is threat to humanity.
- Palash Biswas uploaded and posted 2 months ago
Hi!It is my live Blog to address you directly as we all stand for Humanity and Nature worldwide!
Posts
No comments:
Post a Comment